|

Smokin’ Ed’s / Puckerbutt Pepper Company – East Coast Seafood Sauce (Hot)

Bitter: ๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸกโ—‹โ—‹

Salty: ๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸกโ—‹โ—‹โ—‹

Sour/Tangy:๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸกโ—‹โ—‹โ—‹

Sweet: ๐ŸŸกโ—‹โ—‹โ—‹โ—‹

Umami: ๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸกโ—‹โ—‹

Heat: ๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸกโ—‹โ—‹โ—‹โ—‹โ—‹

Quick Flavor Notes: Earthy, Garlicky, Savory, Piquant

Recommended: Yes

Texture: Thick with small soft chunks

Ingredients: Water, Vinegar, Onion, Garlic, Old Bay Seasoning, Chili Powder.

In my opinion nowhere in the USA does seafood as well as the Mid-Atlantic. Living in Florida now I’ll admit that mahi mahi, gulf shrimp, grouper, and stone crabs have their appeal and I’m sure west-coasters will wax poetic about dungeness crabs but for my money nothing beats jumbo-lump crab cakes barely held together by a whisper of binder, sauteed soft-shells with a little lemon or caper butter, or a newspaper-covered picnic table with a bushel of Old Bay steamed blue crabs dumped all over it. I first heard of this particular sauce when it was part of the Costco Puckerbutt box set a year or two ago that my Costco unfortunately never carried. Having tried some other Old Bay hot sauces however I was very intrigued and thankfully saw it during one of the frequent online sales on the Puckerbutt online store and was able to pick it up (along with a good number of others) so was excited to try it.

Smokin’ Ed’s East Coast Seafood Hot Sauce is based on that Mid-Atlantic seasoning staple Old Bay. Old Bay consists of a heavy amount of celery salt, red and black pepper, paprika, and a number of unnamed spices. People who’ve attempted to reverse-engineer the recipe have come up with spices including mustard, mace, cloves, nutmeg, allspice, coriander seed, and more. It’s savory, aromatic, and the perfect accompaniment to enhance the sweet natural flavor of seafood. In addition to the Old Bay this sauce has onions and garlic to further boost the savory aspects plus of course vinegar. The big elephant in the room, as it is with almost all Smokin’ Ed’s sauces, is that he doesn’t disclose the peppers actually used in the sauce. Ed Currie’s paranoia about that does make me hesitant to buy more of his sauces than I already have as transparency and full-disclosure of ingredients are things that are very important to me with any hot sauce brand. For East Coast Seafood Hot Sauce Ed simply lists “chili powder” so we know it’s a dried and ground pepper instead of a fresh one. On his website for this sauce he does mention that it contains Pepper X, however there’s also a Pepper X version of this sauce with the same text. I would assume the Pepper X version has more Pepper X in the bottle, though it doesn’t say whether or not other chiles are used in either.

Like most Puckerbutt and Smokin’ Ed Sauces East Coast Seafood Hot Sauce is thick in consistency, something that surprised me a bit given that it uses dried peppers and not a mash. There are some little lumps in it, perhaps from the onions and garlic. You can tell this sauce has super-hots in it from the aroma which presents the telltale burning sensation as you sniff it. When it comes to a lot of brands when they label their sauce simply as “hot” it ends up being barely above mild at best. When Ed Currie does it he means it’s going to be hot and this is no exception. This does have that ghost-pepper-adjacent Pepper X flavor that’s earthy and a little bit smoky while also having a brighter pepper flavor, so perhaps there’s some reaper powder in this as well. The sauce is chile-forward but the onions and garlic also come through giving depth to the sauce. The Old Bay flavor steps in after that initial chile pepper heat and flavor and many of the ingredients in Old Bay such as the celery, mustard, and black pepper pair naturally well with chile peppers. The spices in the Old Bay also help make the sauce feel satisfyingly salty even with only 40mg of sodium per serving. With the spice blend, aromatics, and strong chile flavor this sauce also doesn’t come across as overly vinegary though there is enough tang and acidity to keep it from tasting dull. Celery seed also has a pronounced umami flavor, one reason I love it in hot sauces, including this one. The burn from East Coast Seafood Sauce starts off moderate but grows over time with a long tail.

Being called a Seafood Sauce I had to try this with seafood first. Continuing my quest to make extra room in my freezer I thawed and grilled some frozen shell-on shrimp, brushing some of this sauce on them as they cooked and then using it as a dipping sauce after. With the strong chile pepper taste it’s different from sprinkling pure Old Bay seasoning but it still worked very well, even if with the heat I had to go through a lot of tea with dinner. One of my favorite french fry accompaniments is Old Bay and vinegar (something I was originally turned on to decades ago at the Deerhead Hot Dogs in Wilmington, DE, the best hot dog place I’ve ever been). Since these combine the vinegar and Old Bay in one, along with the chiles and more, I found this sauce to be awesome with french fries, though I doubt it’ll replace the pure Old Bay and malt vinegar for me. Finally I tried this on a fried chicken sandwich and that may be the best application I found. The earthy depth from the Pepper X combined with the umami and complexity of the Old Bay worked with the mayo, pickles, and fried chicken like they were meant for each other.

While I’m very much not a fan of Ed Currie’s insistence on obfuscating the peppers (and often other ingredients) in his sauces as if there would be some grand conspiracy to steal his recipes I do very much enjoy this sauce so I’ll give it a recommendation. Smokin’ Ed’s East Coast Seafood Hot Sauce is great on seafood as the label suggests but is in no way limited to it and it packs a nice punch with much better chile flavor than I’d expect from a sauce that relies on powder. If you’re looking for an Old Bay hot sauce that brings way more heat than the McCormick Louisiana style variety this is absolutely worth a try.

Similar Posts

  • |

    Volcanic Peppers – Smokin’ Hot Scarlett

    Bitter: โญโœฐโœฐโœฐโœฐ Salty: โญโญโญโœฐโœฐ Sour/Tangy: โญโญโญโœฐโœฐ Sweet: โญโœฐโœฐโœฐโœฐ Umami: โญโญโœฐโœฐโœฐ Heat: โญโญโญโญโœฐโœฐโœฐโœฐโœฐโœฐ Quick Flavor Notes: Fresh, tangy, bright, earthy, smoky Texture: Medium-thin with some seeds and garlic bits Recommended: Yes Ingredients: Chile Peppers (Cayenne, Ghost), Vinegar, Water, Sugar, Garlic, Xanthan Gum, Vitamin C Hailing from Nebraska Volcanic Peppers’ origin started way back in 2009 with…

  • |

    The Crabby Shack – Zesty Lemon Pepper Hot Sauce

    Bitter: ๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸกโ—‹โ—‹โ—‹ Salty: ๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸกโ—‹โ—‹โ—‹ Sour/Tangy:๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸกโ—‹ Sweet: ๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸกโ—‹โ—‹ Umami: ๐ŸŸกโ—‹โ—‹โ—‹โ—‹ Heat: ๐ŸŸกโ—‹โ—‹โ—‹โ—‹โ—‹โ—‹โ—‹โ—‹โ—‹ Quick Flavor Notes: Sour, tart, lemon, sweet Recommended: Yes Texture: Thin with some small spice bits Ingredients: tomatillos, filtered water, yellow bell peppers, white distilled vinegar, habanero pepper, lemon pepper seasoning (sugar, citric acid, black pepper, garlic powder, salt, onion powder, lemon peel, thyme)…

  • |

    Hormel – Beef Tamales in Chili Sauce

    Bitter: ๐ŸŸกโ—‹โ—‹โ—‹โ—‹ Salty: ๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸก Sour/Tangy: ๐ŸŸกโ—‹โ—‹โ—‹โ—‹ Sweet: ๐ŸŸกโ—‹โ—‹โ—‹โ—‹ Umami: ๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸกโ—‹โ—‹ Heat: ๐ŸŸกโ—‹โ—‹โ—‹โ—‹โ—‹โ—‹โ—‹โ—‹โ—‹ Quick Flavor Notes: Salty, savory, beefy, smoky Recommended: Yes Texture: Soft with some cornmeal resistance Ingredients: Water, Beef, Tomatoes (water, tomato paste), Corn Meal, Corn Flour, Contains 2% or less of Modified Corn Starch (contains erythorbic acid), Masa Flour (ground corn, trace of…

  • |

    Jake’s Nut Roasters – Fire Roasted Hatch Chile Almonds

    Bitter: โญโญโญโญโœฐ Salty: โญโœฐโœฐโœฐโœฐ Sour: โญโœฐโœฐโœฐโœฐ Sweet: โœฐโœฐโœฐโœฐโœฐ Umami: โญโœฐโœฐโœฐโœฐ Heat: โญโœฐโœฐโœฐโœฐโœฐโœฐโœฐโœฐโœฐ Quick Flavor Notes: Dusty, peppers, dirt, tang, hint of fire Texture: Crunchy and dry Recommended: Conditional Ingredients: Whole Dry Roasted Almonds, Salt, Maltodextrin, Jalapeno/Hatch Chile Pepper, Spices, Citric Acid, Natural Flavor, Tapioca Starch I don’t really care for almonds. I’ve always found it…

  • |

    El Yucateco – Habanero and Grilled Pineapple Hot Sauce

    Bitter: ๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸกโ—‹ Salty: ๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸกโ—‹โ—‹ Sour/Tangy:๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸกโ—‹ Sweet: ๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸกโ—‹ Umami: ๐ŸŸกโ—‹โ—‹โ—‹โ—‹ Heat: ๐ŸŸก๐ŸŸกโ—‹โ—‹โ—‹โ—‹โ—‹โ—‹โ—‹โ—‹ Quick Flavor Notes: Astringent, artificial, sweet Recommended: No Texture: Syrupy and mostly smooth Ingredients: Water, Sugar Cane, Habanero Peppers, Pineapple, Lemon Juice, Salt, Spice And Colouring (Turmeric), Xanthan Gum (Stabilizer), Gellan Gum (Stabilizer), Acetic Acid (Ph Control Agent), Citric Acid (Acidulant), Natural Flavouring (Onion),…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *